Libby, Maggie, and Sally find themselves pregnant at the same, with their babies due at Christmas time. Born within weeks of each other, the three little girls, dubbed the "Presents from Heaven, have grown enough for their mothers to return to Maggie's Café full-time. But trouble brews when Maggie's archrival brings an international coffee franchise to Little Creek to destroy all that Maggie and her friends have worked for to make their café so successful.

The women have their own issues to contend with while putting all their energy into doing whatever is necessary to save their business. A mishap challenges them to consider what is truly important. Will they be able to hold onto Maggie's café?