Jordan has never quite fit in. He lives with a crippling fear of doors, he has this cringing need to bury dead things, and his friendship with Jaylene Cooper died a slow, painful death after he refused to date her.

When he's given the advice to find someone normal to copy, it's a no brainer for Jordan to choose Chase. Chase is popular, knows about Jordan's quirks, and has a girlfriend. He's also Jaylene's brother. But there's a big problem. The more time Jordan spends with Chase the more he realizes he doesn't want to be like Chase, he wants to kiss him.

But his new feelings are the least of his worries. There's a killer loose. And when the bodies start dropping, one with a similar scar as his own, Jordan becomes the prime suspect. As he begins to unravel the crime, it becomes clear that he's not the only one with secrets. Haunted by a past he doesn't remember, Jordan has to face what lies behind the door before he becomes the next victim.